Posted by psgels on 29 July 2009 with categories: Anime Reviews



I’m not the biggest fan of romantic comedies, mostly because a lot of them are pretty cliched and boring. Nevertheless there obviously also are a lot of gems. His and Her Circumstances is Gainax and Hideki Anno’s addition to this genre, and while it may on the outside seem like the umpth variation of the same formula, it rises above most others through its dialogue, deep characters and snappy direction.

I have to grant it to Hideki Anno: as infamous as Gainax has become over the years, HaHC features some of the best direction I have seen in a romantic comedy. It doesn’t feel like a moment is wasted here, the dialogue is elaborate and meaningful and he really managed to bring out the depth of the characters from whatever manga this was based on. It turns this into a very accessible series: it’s very easy to watch and hardly ever gets boring. It may not be consistently funny, but it is consistently entertaining (well, with ONE major exception, but I’ll get to that below).

The dialogue overall flows very naturally, and of course the trademark Gainax Animation is very evident through the series, but you can see that along the way, the budget of this series becomes smaller and smaller. Nevertheless, the creators of this series solve it really well, and in a completely different way from how a limited budget is usually masked (by things like distorted faces and an overabundance of still frames). This series excels in its smart and creative tricks to save budget; the art remains crisp and consistent and the creators never forget to have lots of things going on at the same time. Two episodes in particular stand out in this: one consists out of uncoloured character-sketches, while the other is basically a living storyboard in black and white. They were a lot of fun to watch because even though it definitely looked cheap, there was always something going on in the screen and the characters never ceased to be captivating.

This does get taken too far in one aspect, though: Hideki Anno’s really weird obsession with recaps. Seriously, this show is full of the: nearly every episode starts with a recap of what happened up to that point, sometimes even lasting for three minutes. If this series had a complex story then okay, it might have been excused, but for a romantic comedy? In the middle, there also is a string of two completely useless recap episodes in the middle, and my guess would be that the total amount of time this series has spent on recapping is about the same as Wolf’s Rain’s recap block. And that one was aired for a good reason. And not spread across the entire series.

Nevertheless though, this series is a great example of a romantic comedy that’s deep and entertaining at the same time. Sure, it does have a bit of an inconclusive ending, but it’s nowhere near a bad conclusion. It’s a great example of how to correctly save budget without sacrificing style. And hey, after watching this series I finally know what the favourite anime of Akiyuki Shinbo is. ^^;

Storytelling: 9/10
Characters: 9/10
Production-Values: 8/10
Setting: 8/10

15 Responses

  1. Mike says:

    This sure brings back memories :D

    Karekano immediately became my favorite romantic comedy, for exactly the reasons you stated. Though I have to say that while Gainex and Anno added their own flair to the story, a lot of it came from the original manga.

    The conclusion, or rather the lack of one, is probably due to them catching up to the source material(at a bad spot too, as the story was at a transition point), as the manga was nowhere near complete at that point. I like how they decided to stick with the story and didn’t go off to create their own ending.

  2. Camario says:

    Actually, the curious thing about the non-ending is that there’s something that could technically count as one, figuratively speaking, just a few episodes back. Don’t really remember the details after all this time, but I’m very sure that was the case.

    The big thing about the series would certainly be characterization, first and foremost, followed by the stylistic quirks and quasi-experimentation.

    Although I agree, they did go a bit too far at times and there’s no way to applaud the excessive amount of recaps, at the very least the majority of the series was definitely very worthwhile. I should probably re-watch it at some point.

  3. senerikfred says:

    The recaps are annoying, but otherwise, Gainax used to be pretty creative in dealing with budget problems. My favorite is the last episode of Gunbuster-the budget saving tricks actually make it feel more epic than it could’ve otherwise, and it features one of the only good examples of partial-nudity in anime.
    The manga actually gets a little too angsty later on, (from what I’ve heard,) but it’d be nice to see if Anno could’ve done anything to smooth that over into a more polished storyline.

    Full agreement with all who declare Kare Kano awesome.

    (Also, failure to resist grammar nazi instincts because I’ve seen you do this before, when you put an adjective after a verb, it becomes an adverb, and must end in -ly. flows natural should be flows naturalLY. Just make sure you never do that to ‘well,’ which is an adverb rather than an adjective to begin with.)

  4. bravejaf says:

    I hate saying it but this anime really did not do the manga justice at all. The manga is truly special, along with Fruits Basket it is one of my favorite romantic comedy manga to date. The ending of the manga was also part of what made this series so special. Along with Clamymore and Berserk this is one of the top manga I want to see completely redone in anime form.

  5. dm says:

    I’m afraid I differ with bravejaf, I think the anime did a fine job of covering the first nine volumes of the manga. Or rather: they did a fine, comedic job of covering those volumes; the manga was a bit more serious (though I don’t think it was the better for it).

    I’ve also excused the non-ending with a citation of the series’ title — “His and her circumstances”. The series can be viewed as being about Arima and Miyazawa’s relationship, or it can be viewed as about the “circumstances” of several different hims and hers (Miyazawa/Arima, Shibahime/step-brother, Miyazawa-mama/Miyazawa-papa, and finally the Miyazawa-jock-friend/returnee from Okinawa. As the series “concludes”, these circumstances will go on.

    Anno and Gainax did a lovely job of bringing the shoujo-manga page to life, and also did some fun things with animation alternatives (the cardboard-cut-out episode remains one of my favorite episodes of anime).

  6. Ialda says:

    Best romantic comedy, best series Gainax ever made, even for all its flaws and short-comings.

    The first 4 episodes especially were a near-perfect set of plot, humor, characterization and good, well-paced realisation. It stays in your memory, even years after.

  7. Longhaul says:

    Severe budget issues and Anno leaving gainax midway through the show were really apparent.

    “(the cardboard-cut-out episode remains one of my favorite episodes of anime)”

    same

  8. steveberry says:

    I actually made a movie out of the first 4 episodes a few years back. Have it as a homemade DVD. It’s a wonderful watch. Easily the best part of the show. Those first 4 eps are perfect– not a wasted moment, and very…. sincere. ?? Good stuff.

  9. Ebod says:

    Personally, I found the manga of Kare Kano to be a bore, so I never checked out the anime, but you seemed to have rated it so high so maybe I’ll give it another chance when I have the time.

  10. blue says:

    This series was amazing up until the ending, just completely ruined it for me =(. Though haven’t got around to the manga yet.

  11. hurin says:

    Other than the endless recaps I had two big problems with that series. One was the non ending, the anime just stops in the middle of the school festival arc, the other was that Arima felt like a Mary Sue character.

    Despite its flaws, it is still my number one romantic series, Toradora comes close as number two.

  12. saku says:

    “he really managed to bring out the depth of the characters from whatever manga this was based on.”

    Sheesh, what an unpleasant thing to say! As everyone commenting here already knows, it comes from the manga of the same name – shortened to KareKano.

  13. zxclobber says:

    Didn’t like how it ended either… is there gonna be continuation to the series? ever? T_T

  14. Shiro, Long Tail's says:

    Sounds interesting, I’ll check it out sometime.

  15. dalojo says:

    An amazingly rich and realistic love story I count among my favorite anime of any genre, which is all the more amazing considering it is basically an incomplete series that was never and will never be completed, and had way too much filler.

    *****************************************

    SPOILER ALERT!!! Do not read on if you have not seen the anime.

    *****************************************

    Also, to date, this is the only rom-com anime I’ve seen where the couple actually makes love. GAINAX’s execution here is just about perfect. So many shows just beat around the bush with sex (NPI), but Anno & Co. handle it with a great amount of dignity and beauty.

Leave a Reply

Shoutbox

Name:
Email:
For:  
Mail will not be published
  • Kaiser Eoghan
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 10:19 AM)
    I’ll freely admit that my bias’s will make me actively just avoid something entirely or have me set with a pre-opinion at times, but at others I’m always willing to give something I’ll probably not like a chance to see if it’ll surprise me.
  • Masky
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 08:30 AM)
    @Helghast: Thats always the best way to do when looking for other people’s opinion on a fictional work. Watching just one or two people’s opinions becomes sort of a echo chamber.
  • Masky
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 08:29 AM)
    I’m more of pointing out that I don’t see a bias being a reason to avoid watching someone’s work rather than trying to counter whether guy is too biased or not since I don’t really care either way.
  • Masky
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 08:28 AM)
    @AidanAK47: Thats because I’m not trying to “counter your point” :D I have watched guy’s series on why Asterisk War sucks and not much of anything else because none of episode titles grabbed me.
  • HelghastKillzone
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 06:45 AM)
    That’s why I watch other Youtubers other than just Digibro and then come to my own conclusions afterwards. I think that’s the best way to go about judging anime. I did like his series on the Asterisk War on going into the details on why it sucks so hard and comparing it to Chivalry of a Failed Knight.
  • AidanAK47
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 02:41 AM)
    I ain’t denying that people have bias. Just that stating that doesn’t really counter y point that Digibro has too much bias and he doesn’t see it.
  • HelghastKillzone
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 02:11 AM)
    I’m not being bias at all when I say that Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress is the best anime in the history of anime. 5/7. Would Kabaneri again.
  • AidanAK47
    (Friday, Jun 24. 2016 12:12 AM)
    @Masky, not sure what kinda point you were trying to make here so let me back up.
    I say I don’t like the guy because he’s too biased and he doesn’t know it.
    You say how would I know that he doesn’t know he’s too biased? I say I can see if from his videos.
    You say everyone has a degree of bias….you aren’t exactly countering my points here.
  • Masky
    (Thursday, Jun 23. 2016 10:58 PM)
    @AidanAK47: Ay, I’m not trying to issue a challenge here, I’m expressing my belief that “educated opinion” is still a form of bias that everyone has and that is okay :D After all, its not like anyone really judges things in vacuum.
  • AidanAK47
    (Thursday, Jun 23. 2016 10:49 PM)
    @Masky, Dare you to find a post with me doing that. Even with my beloved fate I do think I at least hold myself back quite a bit. If anything when I really get into something I start criticizing it harder.

1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · »

Featured Posts

Joker Game Review – 50/100

When experiencing the wave of new anime each season it can get rather tiresome to notice all the teenagers fighting supernatural forces while gathering a harem through seer luck or similarly tired concepts. So when something like Joker game comes along and takes a road less traveled with it’s story, naturally I am well on […]

Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress – 10

After the Horobi’s laser light show and having Biba-sama completely dominate the narrative with his super cool looking henchmen, Koutetsujou no Kabaneri is back on track although it’s on different rails for here on out. Imprisoned by the Hunters and being caught in the middle of the impending final conflict between the Shogun and Biba, […]

mayoiga 07b

Mayoiga Review – 78/100

Mayoiga has to be one of the most misunderstood shows in recent years. On a surface, the premise alone has a lot of potential. The idea behind putting 30 people, each of them has very different set of personalities, together in a bus to a mysterious lost village, in order to start over new life […]

Joker Game - 12 2

Joker Game – 12

Upon finishing yet another rather uneventful episode of Joker Game, I began to wonder just what this series had planned for its finale. “How best to top off a rather mediocre series such as this?” I thought to myself. However when looking over general consensus over the episode I found out that I seen the […]

Re Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu - 12 4

Re:Zero -Starting Life in Another World – 12

This looks to be the weakest episode of Re:Zero to date which does seem to be a trend when it comes to the arcs of the series. When looking over these twelve episodes I have come to find that the weakest episodes of the series are the first episode of an arc which does make […]

Mayoiga 12d

Mayoiga – 12 (end)

Mayoiga pretty much wraps up its story this week and for the series that focus much about anti-climaxes and inconsistency, this ending neatly conclude all of its main loose end. In the final twist of Mayoiga, it turns out that Koharun is God’s daughter (now I understand the inclusion of him in Mayoiga) and all […]

Kiznaiver - 11 3

Kiznaiver – 11

I believe I finally figured out something much like Agata of this episode did. Over the course of watching Kiznaiver something in the back of my mind bugged me about it. It was something I couldn’t quite put my finger on but after watching this episode I believe it’s finally hit me. I now know […]

Bungou Stray Dogs 11d

Bungou Stray Dogs – 11

Bungou Stray Dogs strays to another side stories this week, it’s pretty much set up for the second cour, and in that aspect this week is a success one, both gives us a new light to existing characters and makes quite a bit of impression on our new characters. I kind of appreciate how the […]

Joker Game - 11 2

Joker Game – 11

Sometimes I wonder if Joker Game is intentionally trying to kill my sense of disbelief as it really does pull out some mind numbingly dumb things from time to time. Today’s “What!” moment comes right at the start of the episode when a young Yuuki escapes imprisonment by blowing up a live grenade in his […]

Latest Reviews

Joker Game Review – 50/100

When experiencing the wave of new anime each season it can get rather tiresome to notice all the teenagers fighting supernatural forces while gathering a harem through seer luck or similarly tired concepts. So when something like Joker game comes along and takes a road less traveled with it’s story, naturally I am well on […]

mayoiga 07b

Mayoiga Review – 78/100

Mayoiga has to be one of the most misunderstood shows in recent years. On a surface, the premise alone has a lot of potential. The idea behind putting 30 people, each of them has very different set of personalities, together in a bus to a mysterious lost village, in order to start over new life […]

akTwkhF

Stella Glow Game Review-60/100

I really should be getting Grand Kingdom or waiting for Mirage Sessions. My review of Stella Glow is way past relevancy being nearly 8 months late, but I finally completed this and it wouldn’t hurt to briefly wrap up my thoughts about the game created by the now-defunct Imageepoch. I somehow managed to get through Lord of […]

rs33

Odin Sphere Leifthrasir Game Review – 87/100

Oh my. This game was just utterly, utterly incredible when it came out, so despite disliking the usual remasters (ahem, Valkyria Chronicles), I was pretty stoked when I learned I’d be able to play this again on better hardware. It came out really late into the PS2’s lifetime in 2007, so at the time, I […]

romance of 3 kingdoms

Chinese Animation Guide – Part 4: Chinese Traditional Animated shows

Welcome to the last part of our Chinese animated guide. This part will cover Chinese traditional art style, for me personally this is the most enjoyable group. The first thing you might notice in these shows are they were in different format ratio, lean more towards the Academy ratio format. I always find their traditional art […]

20160513001913_1

Lucid9: Inciting Incident Video Game Review – 85/100

It’s not often I pick a game up without prior knowledge. I abhor the act of pre-ordering and at least do a google search on the title to get a general idea of it’s overall quality. Gone are the day you walk into a game store and buy something purely on a whim or the […]

The Totem Warrior

Chinese Animation Guide – Part 3: Haoliners inputs

This part we explore one Chinese animation studio’s works. I choose Haoliners partly because they are independent studio, and their works are not hard to find. Just established in 2013, Haoliners is an indie studio but gathered more reputation in the last few years in their homeland. My experience with them through those titles below […]

Cover

Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress OST Review

This will be the first time in my anime blogging career that I have ever done one of these anime OST review. It should be known that I have a complete bias for Hiroyuki Sawano as he has become one of the biggest composer for anime in recent years in some of my favorite anime […]

Nüwa’s Growth Diary

Chinese Animation Guide – Part 2: Chinese Anime shows

As much as I hated the term Chinese Anime (Anime stands for Japanese animation, strictly speaking), this is the exact term for those shows. Their influence from the Anime was so heavy that apart from the voice cast and some scene settings, you can’t tell those apart from the original anime. With that said, judge from […]