Posted by psgels on 10 December 2011 with categories: Anime Reviews

Makoto Shinkai got famous for his movies and short films that were just completely unique and unlike anything else in anime. I always found it really hard to judge these movies, but there is one thing that I want to praise all of them for: their sense of distance.Even after watching so many anime, I never encountered any other anime that portrayed that so well and indescribably.

Now even though I’m saying this: Hoshi wo Ou Kodomo is completely different from his previous work. Apart from She and Her Cat they were all simple romances. This is an adventure movie. In fact, Makoto Shinkai watched a lot of Ghibli movies inbetween directing this one and 5cm/Second, and this really can be viewed as his portrayal of a ghibli movie. With that, I’m not saying that it’s a Ghibli-rip off, by the way. This movie definitely takes the

classic Ghibli style into a different direction compared to Miyazaki’s change over the past 10 years. Clocking in at two hours, this is a slow-paced adventure movie about a random schoolgirl and teacher of her. It makes use of its slow pacing by animating the two characters very life-like. The acting is very realistic without any weaknesses or bad lines. The world it takes place in is very creative and full of ideas, and feels very believable for a fantasy world. A lot of work went into making the characters easy to relate to here, and Makoto Shinkai really succeeded in this.

This movie definitely is more accessible than Makoto Shinkai’s previous movies. That does have its downsides, though. The sense of distance that I mentioned above: this movie has it too, but while the previous movies gave unique interpretations to this theme, in this movie it simply turns into “death”, which has a bit less substance and has been done before many times. And unfortunately, better. Overall the biggest flaw of this movie that it seems to lack a bit of substance here and there. Its messages are simple, the characters are simple, and the setting, instead of going in-depth on one of its ideas instead remains on the surface with a bunch of ideas inspired by random ancient cultures, ranging from Middle America to ancient south-west Asia. It’s pretty much a family movie… for a bit of an older audience than usual, perhaps. This does have gore, so if your son or daughter can’t stand blood then you might want to give this movie a pass.

What stands out the most here are the visuals. Oh my god, these are gorgeous. This movie is two hours long and absolutely chock full of all sorts of visual ideas. I mean, like I said: Makoto Shinkai is inspired by Ghibli this time, but it still is undoubtedly a Makoto Shinkai movie. The artistic direction is a brilliant blend of the two styles and while the budget of this movie may not be as big as your average Ghibli movie, the animation is still very life-like, some frames are incredibly fluid, and the background art is just absolutely fantastic. Here, he actually surpassed Ghibli with its sheer versatility.

And really, this isn’t one of those movies that are all style and no substance. It still stands out as a very solid and enjoyable movie, but I do feel that Makoto Shinkai could have gone more in depth to his material.

Storytelling: 8/10 – Believable storytelling, slow but very good pacing and kept my attention through the whole movie.
Characters: 8/10 – Realistic characters, albeit a bit one-sided.
Production-Values: 9/10 – Amazing background art.
Setting: 8/10 – Imaginative, though not very deep.

Suggestions:
Yona Yona Penguin
Gedo Senki
Princess Mononoke

12 Responses

  1. Firechick says:

    I think this movie is supposed to go in depth about getting over the loss of someone instead of just death in itself. Lots of people cope with loss in different ways. Shin lost Shun and copes by fighting, Asuna lost her father and managed to get along fine, Morisaki lost his wife and wants to bring her back, and Manna, the little girl whom Asuna helps, lost her mother and has stopped speaking (speaking of which, did you know the character designer for Konnichiwa Anne worked on this, and that the little girl is voiced by Anne’s seiyuu? Hidaka-sama!! <3). I loved this movie to death. I don't care if people think it's a Ghibli rip-off.

  2. VyseLegend says:

    Alot of people crapped all over this movie saying its shallow/Ghibli ripoff, what have you. I agree with your review for the most part, however. Overall I thought this was a pretty good movie but its not exactly revolutionary or anything.

  3. gan says:

    Have u seen 5 centimeters per second psgels?I was looking for your review on it but couldn’t find it. (Asked because these 2 are from the same directors right?)

  4. psgels psgels says:

    gan: I watched it, but indeed couldn’t write a review about it. It’s an udescribable movie that does one thing really, really well, and yet felt a bit empty.

    And yeah, obviously this is inspired by Ghibli, but I believe that nowadays people are way too quick in labelling something a rip-off. This movie had enough points that made it stand apart from Ghibli.

  5. gandalf8 says:

    For me, this movie could be surmised in one sentence :- astounding animation and artwork with a well-worn but still interesting setting let down by its weakly characterized cast, an inefficiently developed storyline, and an unsatisfying conclusion to a few of the plot threads.

  6. andrea says:

    Come on, there is a scene taken straight from Princess Mononoke when the boy cuts his hair and goes off with the horse while saying goodbye to his girl. It’s the EXACT same scene. This is worse than Gedo Senki

    • psgels psgels says:

      If we’re going to label individual scenes: how many Ghibli movies visibly cut off the hand of one of their underaged characters? How many Ghibli movies are about a giant hole in the ground? How many Ghibli movies are about a teacher who works as a hitman and wants to bring back his dead wife? In the same way you can criticize 5cm/Second for having teenaged romance in it.

      • andrea says:

        It doesn’t make any sense to pick small things from the movie that are not in the Ghibli ones. Who cares if there are not giant holes and hitmen\teachers in Ghibli products. But anyway

        The giant hole is just a variation on the forbidden land where you gain a long forgotten dangerous power like the castle in the sky from Laputa

        In Princess Mononoke the main character cuts either an arm or a head (I don’t remember which one right now) off an enemy, and he himself is at risk of losing his hand during the whole movie

        And really, asking me for a resemblance as specific as a hitman\teacher is just silly and forced. But there are plenty of characters in Ghibli that seem to be evil at first and show later on their good side.

        These things don’t really matter; the point is, a good chunk of this movie was (badly) ripped off from Ghibli movies, and whatever Makoto Shinkai ended up adding was bad, resulting for an overall mediocre film.

        • Wyrdwad says:

          The hair being cut off is not actually unique to Princess Mononoke. It’s an aspect of traditional Japanese literature that’s been seen in more anime, games and novels than you can count. Final Fantasy IX, for example, has Princess Garnet cutting her hair in exactly the same fashion. It’s symbolic of giving up one’s innocent, spoiled life and setting out to blaze a new trail toward the future. Calling out Shinkai for “copying” this from Princess Mononoke is no different than calling out Miyazaki for “copying” it from any number of classic Japanese poems.

  7. jzar says:

    Shinkai took inspiration and exact parts from Miyazaki’s work and yet where he tried to be creative with his story telling he failed. The art is wonderful but the story telling was so poor that it hurt the film. The main characters where fine but none of the actions felt real to me.

    I’ve encountered this kind of thing before, one of my old art directors brought in an ‘original’ story, that was almost exactly the star wars story. It was hard to get him to change it. He thought it was great. Thankfully the producer didn’t give him a green light and we avoided making that script.

    I don’t mind derivative art and story but it needs to make a bit more sense. It’s really quite a shame that it failed to tell the tale in an engaging way. I could see where a good editor could really helped here.

    Miyazaki is a rock solid story teller. His work brings you into his world where all the actions make sense and are important. This just didn’t happen here. It was hard to be reminded of Miyazaki and not have a better story teller in charge.

    I was very disappointed with this especially since the art and world were so engaging.

  8. Suumire says:

    Just an opinion here, but I agree with Jzar. The art and atmosphere are phenomenal, so it’s sort of a shame that the story didn’t pull through. I didn’t like a lot of the camera angles or pacing in the beginning of the movie, and while usually I have absolutely no problem with a movie deriving from miyazaki (who cares, I actually enjoy a tip of the hat) there were whole scenes and lots of character’s designs that were mirrored concepts, which I think is the difference.

    I don’t think it would’ve been as noticeable if the story really nailed it, but overall there was a hard time with pacing and focus in my opinion, which is sad since they had a really great message going on.

    I really wish it had been better thought out and pushed its boundries. I would’ve killed to see a little more of that sci-fi feel that was around the amazing life/death pit and reminded me of those gorgeous Shinkai paintings. maybe I just really did miss the sort of melancholy, emotional mood that comes with his movies.

  9. theowne says:

    I never thought of Shinkai as being a great storyteller – he’s more of a painter. He can capture moods and emotions as snapshots on a visual medium. “5cm per second” is a great example – capturing the emotion of loneliness and regret using relatively hollow, uninteresting characters.

    But he has done a very poor job sustaining a full length adventure story which attempts to rest on character development and storytelling. I found this film very dull.

Leave a Reply

Shoutbox

Name:
Email:
For:  
Mail will not be published
  • Emma
    (Thursday, May 28. 2015 05:33 PM)
    @Wyatt: My head I reckon goes into an automatic defense thing sometimes I think.
  • Emma
    (Thursday, May 28. 2015 05:32 PM)
    @Wyatt: I wouldn’t personally get off on it particularly either but if I was to be completely honest while I could tell you I thought/knew it was wrong/messed/etc etc it wouldn’t change either way that my response on an emotional level amounts to little more than feeling indifferent/un-affected/unphased.
  • Emma
    (Thursday, May 28. 2015 05:21 PM)
    Finally got round to rewatching Yuasa’s Kemonozume series. This was something I dropped nearly halfway through when I was a teenager because I think I was at a stage where I couldn’t appreciate it, but on a rewatch I think very very highly of it and am genuine impressed with/by it, has pretty much all I’d want in an anime series.
  • WyattX
    (Thursday, May 28. 2015 08:18 AM)
    F’ing hell, now this is a form of hentai I am not okay with. I love gore, & I don’t mind loli, but put those two together and I have an issue. http://pururin.com/gallery/17789/0210564801.html
    As messed up as I am, at least I don’t get off to this, lol.
  • Emma
    (Tuesday, May 26. 2015 02:17 AM)
    I’m going crazy waiting on that new ghost in the shell movie and those two new ovas…
  • Emma
    (Tuesday, May 26. 2015 01:43 AM)
    https://www.livechart.me/fall-2015/all
    Heres a look at the fall season ^
  • AidanAK47
    (Tuesday, May 26. 2015 01:42 AM)
    Better start writing it up. As well as catching up with Arslan though I am not sure if there is a point to that anymore
  • Emma
    (Tuesday, May 26. 2015 01:42 AM)
    Cool, new devilman’s a movie, less worry about censorship then, awesome.
  • AidanAK47
    (Tuesday, May 26. 2015 01:41 AM)
    Ah crap I am gonna have to do a new preview post soon.
  • Emma
    (Tuesday, May 26. 2015 01:38 AM)
    That Aria follow up might be anime original content, having enjoyed the manga years ago, I’m up for more.
    I don’t really know if I care about Ks second season or not I probably won’t watch it.

1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · »

Featured Posts

Khights of Sidonia S2 – 7

Moral of the story, if you build a death star planet destroying ray then you better make sure that it’s not sentient. Though it seems that the dangers of using such weaponry are lost on Kobayashi as even one wiping out the testing facility and a hefty number of people isn’t enough of a red […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 20

This episode wasn’t quite what I expected. It is true that I didn’t get the big fight I was looking for, though there were clashes going on. However this still was a very good episode. So on the matters of Kirei, Rin, Lancer and Shinji it was all done perfectly. Well there was this weird […]

Knights of Sidonia S2 – 3-6

So far the focus has been pretty heavily on Tsumugi, the chimera. Who is strangely moefied. Its really odd to see what is essentially a giant  tentacled monster display the characteristics of a innocent cutsy little girl. Still she is to me one of the better characters of the show. Untainted by the negative aspects […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 19

Oh my god, I can’t believe that Archer is the future Shirou Emiya!….said no one who watched this episode. But yes the cat is out of the bag. Archer is Shirou turned cynical and jaded after playing executioner for a couple of decades. There was a small bit showing how he contracted with the world […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 18

Well here it is. The name drop. The very thing the route is called after. And its….its…kinda bad. Of all the places to make the first visual blunder, why did it have to be here? Well Archers reality marble/noble phantasm Unlimited Blade Works was unleashed and Ufotable thought the best treatment would be to render […]

Knights of Sidonia S2 – 1-2

Even after a long break its nice to see that Sidonia hasn’t lost its edge. The story is still engaging and CG robot battles dynamic. However…was the CG this bad before? I remember it took some time to get used to the CG animation of the last season but this seems especially stiff. The easy […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 16

So at the start of this episode featured the big moment of Gilgamesh ripping out Illya’s heart and it was surprisingly underwhelming. It is true that in context this makes more sense and fits his character better. But it is a little disappointing. Strangely this wasn’t how it was in the visual novel and this […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 15

The word that encompasses this episode in a nutshell would be brutal. Whether you love her or hate her, I say few would believe that Illya deserved this fate. The tragedy is ever more pungent if you know the full details of her past. Anime only viewers may not get the most out of this […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 14

As a reader of the Fate/stay night visual novel I can confirm that the majority of this episode was anime original content. However instead of being about castors history like I thought, it’s of his backstory with her first master. In all honestly making the episode be about her history with Jason would have been […]

Latest Reviews

Shirobako Review – 80/100

When you see a harem anime and sigh as the breasts of the female lead jiggle with every step and wind that can flip a skirt it’s easy to forget that somewhere in Japan a group of people worked hard to get that jiggle right and draw each frame of animation. The hardships of the […]

Clipboard06

Nerawareta Gakuen Review – 84/100

Let me talk a bit about Ryousuke Nakamura. For a long time, this guy was my hero. He started off as an assistant director to Monster, in my opinion a big reason why that series got such a ridiculously solid adaptation, and then in 2008 he came with the groundbreaking Mouryou no Hako. No TV-series […]

Clipboard03

Kick Heart

Okay, so I didn’t want to exit 2013 without having seen Masaaki Yuasa’s Kick Heart. It’s only twelve minutes anyway, and I consider him to be one of the best anime directors out there. The story here is pretty silly and mostly serves as a backdrop, so I mostly want to talk about the nature […]

Clipboard01

Kyousogiga Review – 90/100

Everyone’s taste is different, and that’s a wonderful thing because that allows us to have so many different forms of media that all aim toward their own niche. My blog is obviously written from the perspective of my own taste, and even when a show doesn’t cater to it (which is nearly always), I love […]

Clipboard04

Ore no Nounai Sentakushi ga, Gakuen Lovecome o Zenryoku de Jama Shiteiru Review – 80/100

Noucome! You do not want to know how long I have been waiting for a series like this. More than half a decade, at the very least. Finally a series comes along and puts the incredibly overused harem genre in its place. And it actually does it well. Thank you! So to elaborate: the harem […]

Clipboard01

Pokemon: The Origin Review – 75/100

Normally I try to avoid spoilers with these reviews, but screw it, it’s Pokemon. Pokemon The Origin is a bomb of nostalgia. If you haven’t played Pokemon Red, Blue or Green, then you will not enjoy this one slight bit. This really is made as pure undilluted fanservice for the fans of the first games. […]

Clipboard08

Tamayura – More Aggressive Review – 75/100

I’m not going to dedicate a post for my impression for the final three episodes of this series. It was just too boring to write much about. I guess that that gives a pretty accurate indication of what I think about this series. Right at the start of Tamayura’s second season, I asked one question: […]

Clipboard04

Silver Spoon Review – 86/100

When Noitamina started airing two series per season, it was amazing. It’s a timeslot that on average tends to be aimed at a much older audience than usual, and having two series with the same mentality definitely helped to bring more diversity to anime overall. Unfortunately it’s a schedule that could not be kept up […]

Clipboard07

Yondemasuyo, Azazel-San Z Review – 82,5/100

Reviewing a comedy sequel usually is quite simple: in most cases it just drops the bomb and runs out of inspiration, and in rare cases it actually manages to stay hilarious. The tricky thing with these kinds of series is that you need to remain funny, and you need to have the inspiration for that. […]