Posted by psgels on 17 February 2012 with categories: Anime Reviews, Full Metal Alchemist - Brotherhood

Out of the entire FMA franchise, the worst part for me was the movie to the first season. It just mad eno sense, was badly animated, especially for movie standards, mad a mockery of the characters and the plot, and overall wasn’t the least bit enjoyable. Thankfully, The Sacred Star of Milos is nothing like that, and is actually a pretty good movie.

Let me first debunk some overall fears that arose with the announcement of this movie: do you remember how in the promo art, Winri looked really inaccurate to her designs in the other series? Well, that is because that wasn’t Winry at all. She’s a character original to this movie, and pretty much the main character. I know a few people who were turned off by the art style of it (yeah), but let me tell you that that is no reason to skip this movie. One thing that you do need to take into account that this IS made by different people as the anime staff, so the animation IS different from the style of the TV-series. The character designs in this movie are a bit more rough and simple. This movie also doesn’t really bother to keep its faces consistent. As a tradeoff however, ti did get a lot of very good inbetween animation. It’s been said before, but this movie has some very good action, and especially the choreography of the different action scenes is very good and creative.

So, what about the story? As it turns out, this takes place around the second half of the Brotherhood TV-series. It’s an original story that doesn’t have anything to do with the main storyline of the series, but it does flesh out the world the world it’s set in. As for the plot: it has some good and bad parts. The good parts was that it packed a good amount of twists that were well built up throughout its airtime. It created a new city in the FMA universe, and actually successfully populated it and created an epic storyline around it. Although… near the end it does get a little too epic.

What I mean by that is the following: you can really see that the creators put some good thought into some of the twists that are pulled. Near the end of the movie however, they just run out of time and momentum to keep that up, resulting in a rushed ending and a final villain with very flimsy motives who continues to spout random moral crap at the main characters. The themes and morals also are a part where this movie leaves things to be desired. Like the TV-series, it’s full of morals, and it doesn’t just copy them, but also adds in its own themes. At the end of the movie though, it didn’t really do anything with them, and most of the final quarter was just completely inconsistent with the morals it tried to build up, and not in a way that makes things come together.

So yeah, it’s a very nice movie, which unfortunately suffers of the common flaw of trying to do too much and trying to be too epic. Still, I’d recommend it. It’s a solid movie with likable characters, and I’d say that out of the Primetime Timeslot movies to come out in the recent years, it is so far the most solid and enjoyable.

Storytelling: 8/10 – Solid storyline for a movie that is just about a random story, albeit a bit too short to give everything the time it needs to build up.
Characters: 8/10 – A solid cast, both the old and new characters. The main villain is flimsy, though.
Production-Values: 9/10 – Great action choreography.
Setting: 8/10 – Doesn’t build much on the themes of the TV-series, but does flesh out the world it plays in.

Suggestions:
Cowboy Bebop – Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door
Heartcatch Precure Movie
Metropolis

9 Responses

  1. Cytl says:

    People thought the girl was Winry?

  2. gandalf8 says:

    I have some mixed feelings after watching this movie. It was good to see Ed and Al back in action again, yet I was disappointed with a few aspects of the movie. One, I was hoping that the movie would expand on the FMA universe after the end of the events in the Brotherhood series, but instead it is placed somewhere in the early to the middle of the Brotherhood series timeline. So Ed and Al were not yet acquainted with the people of Xing, namely Lan Fan, Ling Yao and May Chang who are some of my favourite characters. I guess that as Hiromu Arakawa wasn’t connected with the movie, the producers could only create a canon storyline with new characters and villains that we will only see in this movie. This was one of the reasons I usually hated the Naruto movies.

    Second, was the way they treated the supporting cast, namely Winry, Roy Mustang and Riza Hawkeye. They’re role are almost negligible towards the development of the events in the movie. I think that they’re inclusion was mostly to give us viewers the sense of nostalgia at seeing some of the old faces, but they didn’t want to take the spotlight off the new characters in this movie so they only had to take bit parts in the development pf the story. I’m fine with that, but why oh why did they drag Roy and co to Tablecity just so they could be almost useless there? Especially Roy, who was present at that final confrontation against the villain, and what did he do while all that lava was flowing towards the village? He just stood there so that Julia, the main in this movie, could stop the lava.

  3. rever5e says:

    “Like the TV-series, it’s full of morals, and it doesn’t just copy them, but also adds in its own themes. At the end of the movie though, it didn’t really do anything with them, and most of the final quarter was just completely inconsistent with the morals it tried to build up, and not in a way that makes things come together. ”

    this the one of the reason i didn’t like the fma series, trying to force it’s own morality toward the you, yes most show had it own moral but to force your moral toward the viewer, stuff that you think is RIGHT, is pretty weak storytelling in by book. yes I understand fma just a kid show but..

    yes the villain did spout some moral crap, however nothing happen. it pretty much food of thought. that I can accept

  4. Denizen says:

    In general it wasn’t a fantastic movie, but as you said it was pretty freaking good for a TV series spin off. As far as Bones movies go, it was also one of their best – the characters were pretty good and the production was excellent, with a great use of skilled animators where it mattered. The story whilst not original and riveting was tight and involving enough, even with the twists. And whilst the moralistic stuff does fall flat, it didn’t ever fall into the pitfall of complete irrelevancy, though it does jar somewhat with the chronology of the main series as you’d expect.

    It did feel like i’d seen this movie countless times before in other shonen iterations, but if so then this had some of the best execution. I would actually recommend this to people who watched the series, and that’s not often the case.

  5. lolcat says:

    I wish Roy would kick some ass and they didn’t even show his fight with chimeras

  6. Ange says:

    I saw one of the premieres that Funimation showed about a month or so back, and I have to say, I thought it was mediocre.

    While the animation during fight scenes (especially the final one, which was incredibly stylised and gorgeous to look at) were pretty well animated, the rest of the movie looked flat and dull. It wasn’t just the simpler designs, it was the fact that characters seemed to lack any kind of highlights of shadows for three-quarters of the film, giving them a very flat look.

    As others have mentioned, the inclusion of additional canon characters seemed like a cheap grab at fanservice; none of them had any real relevance to the plot, and leaving them out probably would have made the film a little more streamlined. In one extreme case, a character literally walks through the door to deliver two or three lines, them promptly walks back out and disappears for the rest of the movie. (I guess pointless cameos are an art that’s been passed down the Armstrong family for generations.)

    The story itself was well-done, with some genuinely inventive twists and an interesting setting. (It’s kind of a shame, though, that the big twist behind the mysteries of the city turns out to be recycled from a previous location, but…) The new characters were interesting, and the music was pretty nice, too. On top of that, it was great seeing Ed and Al in action again.

    Overall, though, I just really didn’t enjoy the movie as much as you did, but it’s always interesting to see your take on a series.

    • whereisraymustang says:

      Haha i am watching the movie right now, and i just had to find another fan say the magic word: recycled.

      yes, if only mustang…>:)

  7. itsroymustang says:

    :)

  8. Anna says:

    I was quite excited to see this movie, but after watching it, I am sorely disappointed and I feel like I would give this a lower rating than you did. The entire movie just seemed too contrived to me, maybe because its length meant that the story within the movie needed to be condensed. Right from the get-go, I thought that everything moved a bit too quickly and conveniently for my tastes.

    I also thought the whole business about “taking back the Holy land of Milos with the Philosopher’s stone, which will give us the power of the miasma/magma or whatever” totally ludicrous. First of all, they didn’t seem to have any plan for what they would do if they obtained the stone. Even at the end of the story, everything happened by chance and nothing they did was really thought through. Were they just going to barge into enemy base, protecting the one person who actually had the Philosopher’s stone, who would then proceed to blast away all the State Alchemists and thereby take back Milos? And also, what about the residents of the city that they reconquered? I’m sure some of them would protest against being taken over – how would these particular residents have been dealt with? This was never answered in the movie either.
    Secondly, I did not understand the ‘power of the miasma’ bit at all. All I could think was: WTF?

    The moral preaching of the movie also got on my nerves, which is probably because the characters’ morals didn’t have enough buildup and support unlike the FMA series. The characters just very bluntly told the audience their morals rather than show where these morals came from, which did not make them very convincing. Even at the end there was a scene where Al and the girl discussed how she had ‘learned’ that ‘obtaining power did not automatically lead to the fulfillment of her wishes’. This was not very convincing for me because while one of her good friends died, she managed to take back her nation’s independence, and save her brother with the Philosopher’s stone.

    Okay, so I’ve been complaining up until now. As for the good part of the series…I do commend the thoughtfulness behind the plot though, I liked that 3D array idea with the blood pouring into the pipes, and the underground city. The concept was very well thought out, and stuck true to its FMA roots, considering the author was not involved. I could easily see this occurring in the manga. I did have a problem with its execution, but I already ranted on long enough about that.

Leave a Reply

Shoutbox

Name:
Email:
For:  
Mail will not be published
  • Bam
    (Thursday, Dec 18. 2014 02:14 PM)
    This is the gratuitous fan-service done for a purpose that people argued for Kill la Kill, which quite frankly just wasn’t there, but there is no denying that even in this music video some value of the fan-service is sheerly the eye-candy.
  • Bam
    (Thursday, Dec 18. 2014 02:07 PM)
    I am genuinely surprised that ME!ME!ME! hasn’t been brought up to my attention up until now. Meta and tongue-in-cheek criticisms of the Otaku culture aside, Anno has exhibited once again that he is a true visionary. The animation is done by a great team of new talent and the music fits like a glove.
    http://animatorexpo.com/mememe/
  • Emma
    (Thursday, Dec 18. 2014 08:18 AM)
    Other than that I’ve been hearing some pretty unnerving things being thrown around by people, trying to tie sociopathy and autism together, hearing people mistaking autism for sociopathy aswell =<
  • Emma
    (Thursday, Dec 18. 2014 08:12 AM)
    And so Hidan no Aria gets a second season, a spin off, I read the manga adaptation, it was terrible, couldn’t even make fun of it like I did with the first season. Time to bring out the old stashed away dismembering equipment and hunt whose responsible lol
  • WyattX
    (Thursday, Dec 18. 2014 05:44 AM)
    @k-off Umm, everyone’s head looks like it was fracking chopped in half but this might interest you: http://bato.to/read/_/291072/pokemmo-the-webcomic_ch1_by_no-group/9
    I think it’s pretty bad tho.
  • AidanAK47
    (Wednesday, Dec 17. 2014 08:57 PM)
    Well I was planning to put up a post telling people to support the grisaia trilogy to the west kickstarter that started 14 hours ago…but they reached the goal in 14 hour so now I am not sure they need it anymore.
  • Emma
    (Wednesday, Dec 17. 2014 09:36 AM)
    @Vincent: Found the second last paragraph interesting!
  • Bam
    (Wednesday, Dec 17. 2014 09:30 AM)
    All in all a heartbreaking week, since just as the horror of the Australian incident was settling in we had the massacre in Peshawar-Pakistan which left 147 casualties of mostly children. And that’s why I don’t blame the west for demonizing Islam; they’ve always had the most cowardly and despicable representation ever.
  • Vincent
    (Wednesday, Dec 17. 2014 09:20 AM)
  • Vincent
    (Wednesday, Dec 17. 2014 09:19 AM)
    NASA has already developed/ still perfecting that first but, which is exciting.

1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · »

Featured Posts

Recommendation corner 02 – Light novels #1

Its very easy to disregard the light novel genre completely as it is responsible for the creation of quite a number of unoriginal, bad and shameless pandering anime in recent years. However there still are worthwhile stories within the genre. They are just a little less known.   Mushoku Tensei Description: A 34-year-old NEET otaku […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 10

Very nice start to the beginning of the episode with the Unlimited Bladeworks chant. Sure, it has been parodied to kingdom come but I still love it and all it’s broken engrish glory. But now I can say it with certainty. This series is not suitable for being watched weekly. In watching this episode I […]

Nanatsu no Taizai – 10

Fights blew past fast this episode. We had four fights in one episode so my previous fears of this getting dragged look to be untrue.  Notables being the fight between a mystery girl and a holy knight whose head is so disproportionate from his body that you could swear someone took the head of a […]

Gugure! Kokkuri-San- 06-10

So I’ve been gone for a while partially because of work, school, and my political activities, but also because I wanted to try approaching how I review in a (hopefully) interesting way. I’d be interested in hearing your feedback on this, as I am trying to inject more of my own personality into the way […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 09

The pattern continues with another building up episode. Admittedly I find this somewhat disappointing. I feel that this show would be better marathoned than watched weekly as the wait for what is a essentially a build up to the next episode can hamper the experience a bit. As I said before, this show would work […]

Nanatsu no Taizai – 09

The fight between explosives girl and the sins was ended quicker than I thought. When King entered the fight it was settled almost immediately.  King made short work of her as Elaine provided some supposedly badass exposition saying how King is originally known as the king of the fairies, harlequin. I say supposedly because it […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 08

Another episode has come and gone. This episode marking the first casualty of the holy grail war. Looks like Rider is out of the running. It is a bit sad to see her go so unceremoniously and even defeated off screen. Well, we shall see you again in the upcoming heavens feel movie, where you […]

Nanatsu no Taizai – 08

There was a few questionable things here this episode. The episode starts with the new villain quite literally killing herself to enter the kingdom of the dead. Which is a big risk considering it was based on one sentence from a child she was threatening. True being a shounen show there’s likely some magical biology […]

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 07

As expected, this week we have another action filled episode. Queue the pretty explosions and fast paced fighting. It felt too short despite the episode length being just the same as the others. I often find that with a good episode of anime it makes you lose the concept of time as you watch. Making […]

Latest Reviews

Clipboard06

Nerawareta Gakuen Review – 84/100

Let me talk a bit about Ryousuke Nakamura. For a long time, this guy was my hero. He started off as an assistant director to Monster, in my opinion a big reason why that series got such a ridiculously solid adaptation, and then in 2008 he came with the groundbreaking Mouryou no Hako. No TV-series […]

Clipboard03

Kick Heart

Okay, so I didn’t want to exit 2013 without having seen Masaaki Yuasa’s Kick Heart. It’s only twelve minutes anyway, and I consider him to be one of the best anime directors out there. The story here is pretty silly and mostly serves as a backdrop, so I mostly want to talk about the nature […]

Clipboard01

Kyousogiga Review – 90/100

Everyone’s taste is different, and that’s a wonderful thing because that allows us to have so many different forms of media that all aim toward their own niche. My blog is obviously written from the perspective of my own taste, and even when a show doesn’t cater to it (which is nearly always), I love […]

Clipboard04

Ore no Nounai Sentakushi ga, Gakuen Lovecome o Zenryoku de Jama Shiteiru Review – 80/100

Noucome! You do not want to know how long I have been waiting for a series like this. More than half a decade, at the very least. Finally a series comes along and puts the incredibly overused harem genre in its place. And it actually does it well. Thank you! So to elaborate: the harem […]

Clipboard01

Pokemon: The Origin Review – 75/100

Normally I try to avoid spoilers with these reviews, but screw it, it’s Pokemon. Pokemon The Origin is a bomb of nostalgia. If you haven’t played Pokemon Red, Blue or Green, then you will not enjoy this one slight bit. This really is made as pure undilluted fanservice for the fans of the first games. […]

Clipboard08

Tamayura – More Aggressive Review – 75/100

I’m not going to dedicate a post for my impression for the final three episodes of this series. It was just too boring to write much about. I guess that that gives a pretty accurate indication of what I think about this series. Right at the start of Tamayura’s second season, I asked one question: […]

Clipboard04

Silver Spoon Review – 86/100

When Noitamina started airing two series per season, it was amazing. It’s a timeslot that on average tends to be aimed at a much older audience than usual, and having two series with the same mentality definitely helped to bring more diversity to anime overall. Unfortunately it’s a schedule that could not be kept up […]

Clipboard07

Yondemasuyo, Azazel-San Z Review – 82,5/100

Reviewing a comedy sequel usually is quite simple: in most cases it just drops the bomb and runs out of inspiration, and in rare cases it actually manages to stay hilarious. The tricky thing with these kinds of series is that you need to remain funny, and you need to have the inspiration for that. […]

Clipboard05

Gargantia on the Verdurous Planet Review – 81/100

Gargantia on the Verdurous Planet tells the storyline of a planet that is completely submerged, with only giant ships residing on the surface, while one of those ships gets visited by this guy and his AI-mecha from this very technologically advanced civilization. Yes, this show is about world building. What this show managed to do […]