Posted by psgels on 5 January 2013 with categories: Anime Reviews

Poor Medaka Box. Its second season had the worst timing imaginable. Here’s the thing: for the past few years, me and Shounen Jump Adaptations didn’t have the best relationship. Sure, there was the occasional gem with Level E, but most series got on my nerves like no other by taking so many ages to actually get somewhere. There are so many of these adaptation that are paced out too long in order to keep the story going in their constant fear of getting cancelled. The first season of Medaka Box actually took advantage of that by actually doing something interesting within the first 13 episodes. It didn’t take ages to change and move somewhere. There was variety.

And then the past autumn season happened. And the juggernauts of Hunter x Hunter and Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure came and challenged just about every boundary of the shounen genre, showing among the best of what Shounen Jump has to offer. And Medaka Box tried to air is second season alongside those two. Yeah, it paled in comparison, unfortunately.

The first season of Medaka Box was a generic school series that at a certain point goes over 9000. The second season is different, though: it consists out of a collection of fights between people with all sorts of powers. You can see that a lot of thought was put into these powers, how they work and how they can be beaten. It goes further than most shounen fighting series do, and you can see that the series has quite a bit of fun in analyzing all of these powers along with their stories. And that’s about all this series does.

The problem with this series, like most other nisiOisin’s works, is that the balance is lost. The problem is that this series spends so much time and focus at talking and explaining how all these powers work, that it forgets to put focus on the rest. This show aims to break some traditions of the shounen jump genre with how elaborate these powers, but at the same time it also falls in the same pitfalls by having way too many characters pointlessly talking and analyzing the fight.

And the fights themselves… it’s not like they are of the kind that remain interesting for 12 episodes. The first season had novelty: the characters did other things than just fighting. Here, they don’t and it becomes obvious that Gainax didn’t put their top people on this series: for their standards, the animation is rather bland, and feels too much like they directly copied and pasted manga panels and moved a few things here and there, that ends up looking a bit bland.

Then here is another thing: the characters of this series have their wrong priorities.I mean, this series understands that characters need to have back-stories, and those stories are indeed often insightful and all. The show is not good at all at fleshing out its characters, though: most characters jus have one or two sides to them. They’re not fun to watch because all of them are defined by their powers and backstories, instead of their actions, if that makes any sense.

I am indeed a tsundere for nisiOisin: up till now despite my annoyances of him, I have watched every adaptation of his that came out so far, because I do think that he is a talented writer. The tsun in me though is starting to win terrain because of how unbalanced all of his stories are. I really care about the big picture how all the small pieces are used together. I’m missing that a lot with his series due to the obsessive focus he puts on his dialogue and Medaka Box is the same: it had some very interesting ideas. But did I enjoy myself for the most part with this series? Well, only the final two episodes really ended up catching my attention to be honest, but they did not succeed in making up for the rest of the episodes, especially because this season was supposed to be the part where the story really started, and to be honest I prefer the variety of the first season over the second.

Storytelling: 7.5/10 – Lots of dialogue that is well-written, but also gets in the way of the rest of the show.
Characters: 7/10 – They’re not interesting, they have backgrounds, but aren’t fleshed out enough.
Production-Values: 8/10 – Gainax does a decent job. Nothing outstanding, but nothing bad either.
Setting: 8/10 – Lots of interesting ideas being explored. Not interesting enough to really lift the series to a higher level, though.

Suggestions:
Law of Ueki << This show is pretty much Medaka Box if it did focus on actually being fun. Yes, this my favorite comedy ever. That's a big difference there... - Hunter X Hunter
Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure

10 Responses

  1. Avatar Merctrack says:

    The thing with Medaka Box is that it started as a sort of episodic school story, then suffered in the ratings and tried to be a faux Jojo (around this arc), then decided it didn’t care and tried to be a parody of a faux Jojo (post this arc).

    Nishio is a well-noted Jojo fan (he actually wrote a novel based on DIO, though it was universally panned as a “fanfic”), but I don’t think he’s really suited its style. He copies all of the superficial elements of it (the superpowers, the crazy characters, etc) but while Jojo’s charm is in how seriously it takes itself at times, Nishio’s is in the fact that he doesn’t take anything he writes seriously at all.

  2. Avatar Cytl says:

    Medaka Boxis right now one of my favorites ongoing manga series but there were times (mostly those that were adapted in these two seasons) that I seriously hated the series, the characters and the school-life to action genre shifting (as today I’m not even sure why I didn’t drop it back then). When reading again all this arcs I’ve become more lenient towards them, probably because of how much I love the recent ones, but I have to agree with Psgels review about the characters being really shallow and to be honest their skills weren’t even that interesting.
    Actually I only watched the last episode of S2 because it wasn’t in the manga but it had all the feeling of the ongoing Medaka Box. One episode was all it took for Kumagawa and Ashin’in to have more interesting personalities than the earlier Medaka and Zenkichi.
    A third season wouldn’t excite me that much but I would probably watch it, because the minus arc is when the series starts to take the right route: abilities go all out in weirdness and actually crazy personalities (instead of just quirky or with tragic pasts) appear. Again, all of this mostly thanks to Kumagawa.

  3. Avatar Jalapeno Bagel says:

    I think the score is good, perhaps a bit too high in the overall scheme of things. Although I preferred this arc over the first, it really was lackluster in comparison to other series and Gainax’s lukewarm animation didn’t really help. Some of your critiques I don’t agree with, although that’s mainly because they do actually get addressed further on in the series.

    On the topic of you being tsundere for Nisio, I think I’ve come to enjoy his style simply because even though its a long, seemingly uneventful journey to get to the end, the end usually has some sort of a bang that pulls everything in together. So it confuses me a bit to hear you say that you don’t get a big picture with small pieces working together in his series (Medaka Box excluded as I think the big picture still hasn’t been reached even in the manga).

    • Avatar Cytl says:

      In my opinion for Medaka Box the big picture is already into play with the near-equal, the jet black wedding and the secret Shiranui arc. But this may be a misconception from my part considering how the previous arcs were so disperse.

      • Avatar Jalapeno Bagel says:

        @Cytl

        I think it’s on its way, but it hasn’t actually all come together yet. imo, rather than just a deconstruction, I always thought the series was more of a character study on Medaka and with her past, we’re finally starting to get the last pieces.

        • Avatar Cytl says:

          Now that you mentiont it, yeah you’re right. Near the end of all those arcs I’ve felt as if the series were about to the over, yet each arc after the previous shows some new concept using pieces that I hadn’t even considered before.

          • Avatar Jalapeno Bagel says:

            I’ve had the same thoughts. And it is a jump manga. who knows, maybe things are just getting started lol.

  4. Avatar Clinton says:

    While this season was just ok mainly. The next part with Kumagawa is were Medaka Box grew the beard (For real) becoming an excellent series.

  5. Avatar Generic Commentarist says:

    Am I the only one who found the “Good Loser Kumagawa” episode better than the rest of the series? The character is a psycho, the power is plain absurd… it was great.

  6. Avatar Clarste says:

    For the record, the characters are literally defined by their powers, or rather their powers represent their characters. This is actually a large part of the point of the series. Naze actually mentioned it in the series already, with her theory that abnormalities come from the personality. Much later on they start using the word “skill” and “personality” interchangeably as if we were supposed to have known this all along. Medaka IS The End, and Kumagawa IS All Fiction. So… that’s entirely intentional. It’s probably best to think of Abnormal powers as an exaggerated extension of their personality.

Leave a Reply

Star Crossed Anime Blog

7 User(s) Online Join Server

Featured Posts

One Punch Man Season 2 – 11 [Everyone’s Dignity]

https://giant.gfycat.com/SilkyHilariousGiraffe.webm I don’t understand it JC Staff. You make it so difficult for me to like you and by extension, OPM. I want to of course, every week there are these flashes of brilliance. These moments where I think “they understand. They care. They can do it”. And then in the very same episode, you […]

Dororo – 24 [Dororo and Hyakkimaru]

Welcome one and all to the Dororo finale! It’s a difficult one, as parts of it are fantastic, while others just leave me confused. But all in all, I think I enjoyed it, and I definitely don’t regret my time with the series. So, all that said, let’s dive in. Starting off, I think Dororo […]

Fruits Basket (2019) – 12 [You Look Like You’re Having Fun]

More than any other episode, this week is where Fruits Basket embraces its two opposing spectrums the clearest: it’s reverse-harem hijinks of highschool life and romance and its dark drama about the Zodiac members. By that light, we can be able to see this adaptation’s quality by this episode alone. For example, this 2019 is […]

Carole & Tuesday – 11 [With or Without You]

Even with Carole & Tuesday standard, this episode is a letdown with many forced developments to move this predictable story forward. These include 1) Tuesday injures her hand but still manage to perform and win the bracket 2) just right at the moment Tuesday said no one in the family care for her, she gets […]

Sarazanmai – 11 [I Want to Connect, so Sarazanmai]

I must admit that days after watching this finale I still can’t wrap my head around all the events happened in this episode. Sarazanmai ends in a happy tone, something I didn’t expect from Ikuhara to be honest. On the most surface level, it’s a rescue mission from Kazuki and Enta to bring Toi back. […]

Kimetsu no Yaiba – 12 [The Boar Bares Its Fangs, Zenitsu Sleeps]

Welcome all to what is, for me, a very conflicted episode of Kimetsu no Yaiba. Filled with fantastic animation, some well thought out fights and a character I loathe no matter how great his scenes look. Let’s dive in! Starting off, Yaiba looked great this week. I don’t think that’s really up for contention. I have […]

Serial Experiments Lain – 8 [Rumors] – Throwback Thursday

Welcome to another episode of Acid Trip Weekly, also known as, Serial Experiments Lain! This week is one of the most confusing, yet simultaneously coherent episodes of anime I have ever watched. It’s impossible to summarize, so let’s just dive in. Starting off, like I said, this episode was an acid trip, both visually and […]

One Punch Man Season 2 – 10 [The Encirciling Net of Justice]

https://www.sakugabooru.com/data/2c523ad11331508ce3e674f68b79ccf2.mp4 Welcome one and all to a rather surprising week of One Punch Man Season 2! This week the animation was mostly fine, and interesting things happened, so let’s just jump right in! Starting off, I rail against the series a lot, but credit where it’s due. The sections of the Garou fight done by […]

Mix – 11 [Try Pitching]

Good news for all you Mix fans out there: the show is likely to be two cour, as the Wikipedia page for its timeslot doesn’t have a replacement listed until October. That means three more months of baseball, romance, and mystifying Japanese puns before Hero Academia S4 kicks Mix off the air for the fall […]

Latest Reviews

Dororo Anime Review – 55/100

In the modern anime sphere, getting a complete story, start to finish, is a rare thing. As is getting an adaptation for an older work. Dororo however has, through the grace of Twin Engine, managed to get both of these. Based on the 1967 manga of the same name by legendary Mangaka Osamu Tezuka, Dororo […]

[Star Crossed Anime Exclusive] Code Geass: Lelouch of the Resurrection Review – 80/100

I was lucky enough to be at Sakura-con in Seattle on 20 April 2019 for the Funimation’s movie premiere of Code Geass’ third movie with the Director himself, Gorō Taniguchi, along with his senior staff in attendance inside a room full of raving fans. Was it was worth the decade-long wait to have a worthy […]

Paranoia Agent Anime Review – 67/100

In an era of the mundane, where every series is the same moe blob, the weird sticks out. Even the most mediocre series can get attention just by being weird. Paranoia Agent is not mediocre, and it is far beyond simply “weird”. Written and Directed by Satoshi Kon, Paranoia Agent is one of his last […]

Boogiepop wa Warawanai (2019) (Winter 2019) Anime Review – 78/100

Just like the titular character, Boogiepop Phantom the series has become some sort of urban legend itself in this medium. Its Light Novels are amongst the first Light Novel ever released, dating back to mid-90s. Moreover, the franchise has endured the test of time, as it inspires anime, live-action adaptations and Boogiepop is a well-known […]

Kouya no Kotobuki Hikoutai (2019 Winter) Anime Review – 77/100

Coming to Kotobuki, there are lots of aspect that catch my attention: it’s from a famed director Tsutomu Mizushima who can turn the most trashable and genre-able concepts into something intriguing; it’s an CG show about air pilots: it has extended aerial combat set-pieces. Watching it till the end, I have to tip my hat […]

Kemurikusa (2019 Winter) Anime Review – 79/100

Kemurikusa is your very definition of an overlooked gem, one that never really gain much discussion anywhere, but one that has a distinctive style from an up-and-coming auteur who has full control of his projects. Coming to Kemurikusa, all the attention it has came from the fact that it is created by TATSUKI, a mastermind […]

Mob Psycho 100 S2 Anime Review – 87/100

Upon finishing this series, the only question on my mind was how many animators did Bones sacrifice on ONE’s altar to achieve this. Following their prior season, Mob Psycho 100 Season 2 continues Bones adaptation of webcomic and manga author ONE’s 4th work, Mob Psycho 100. ONE has also authored the critically acclaimed One Punch […]

Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai Review – 84/100

Anime draws on many different media types in its endless search for properties to adapt, but manga is still the king of the bunch. And why not? It’s a distinctly Japanese art form, their main demographics have significant overlap, and manga’s panel-based layout means that some of the anime staff’s work is already done. Plenty […]

Kaze ga Tsuyoku Fuiteiru Anime Review – 93/100

Recently, sports anime have become a bit of a dying breed. Falling into the same hole as Mecha, aside from a passionate base audience, most are overlooked. There are the occasional hits like Haikyuu, Yuri on Ice, or Darling in the Franxx for Mecha, but those are few and far between, often taking years. Even […]